Wednesday, July 24, 2013

Yahoo Update:

Investors got a look at how CEO Marissa Mayer is doing in turning around Yahoo YHOO +10.34%. Yahoo reported total second-quarter revenue fell 7%, though revenues were off just 1% when excluding Yahoo’s payouts to its business partners. Earnings were $331 million, or 30 cents a share, up from $227 million, or 18 cents a share, a year earlier. Wall Street expected 30 cents a share in profit.
The Chinese e-commerce giant, in which Yahoo owns a 24 percent stake, nearly tripled its net income in the first three months of the year and increased its revenue by 71 percent

Yahoo has had its earnings call but fillings have not been released yet so it is hard to tell what is going on internally in terms of adjusted/non-adjusted earnings

Yahoo ($29.45 as of 7/17/13) up roughly 90% since I recommended the stock this time last year, is now reaching an overbought valuation.  My original analysis stands, and the fact that Yahoo still owns ~24% of Alibaba is the only reason the company is interesting to look at from an investment perspective.  Every share of Yahoo carries a “free” quarter share of Alibaba along with it.  Yahoo is currently valued at a PE of 7.64.
Since Mayer’s indoctrination, Yahoo has been on a spending spree, sweeping up 17 tech companies since the beginning of Mayer’s tenure, most notable of which was Tumblr, acquired for $1.1B in May 2013.

Yahoo is acquiring both content and software, and ultimately, attempting to compete with Google. 
Yahoo’s business model is relatively simple to understand – it owns a conglomeration of websites which it sells advertising space on.  This part of the business ostensibly works in conjunction with Yahoo’s ad exchange, allowing publishers and advertisers to connect on the Yahoo platform.  Yahoo’s own websites (in this case the publishers) will have an easier time monetizing their advertising inventory through using Yahoo’s proprietary technology.  This bit of vertical integration for Yahoo is definitely a plus.  But now let’s look at the competition:

Google AdEx – Guaranteed inventory, unfilled gets passed to DoubleClick/AppNexus
Yahoo – Guaranteed inventory, unfilled gets passed to Right Media

By all accounts, Yahoo’s software is inferior to Google’s.  At its base, Yahoo is not an ad exchange but a publisher with its own advertising technology. 

The future of the internet advertising industry is relatively grim for publishers, as well as ad networks, DSPs, SSPs, trading desks and exchanges.  The reason for this is largely due to the streamlining of the industry in terms of efficiency.  With the advent of programmatic buying and real time bidding, inventory is being sold closer and closer to its “fair” market value, and as it turns out, advertisers have historically been paying too much for inventory.  As the cost of inventory decreases over time, the amount of ad spend in the overall industry will decrease.

Yahoo will undoubtedly feel the pain of this “CPM” decrease over time, although the absolute amount of pain it will feel depends on the portion of Yahoo’s content that monetizes its inventory through real time bidding or programmatic buying. 

Regardless, the signals are bearish from both an industry and competitive standpoint.  Yahoo content cannot compete with the content available on the web these days, and although the acquisition of Tumblr was a move in the right direction, Yahoo may not have the right type of culture to retain Tumblr users while also turning it into the cash cow the company so desperately needs.  The earnings reported by Yahoo in Q2 2013 were largely augmented by Alibaba’s earnings, whose revenues rose 71% y/y and whose margins increased 51% y/y as opposed to consensus estimates of ~30% margins growth y/y.  Alibaba itself is valued around $14/share, which means each share of Yahoo can be discounted by roughly a fourth of this, meaning what’s being paid for Yahoo alone is roughly $25.95/share.  However, I believe even this valuation is optimistic.


Verdict: Sell